How a raw foods diet can make you sick

By Dr. Ronald Hoffman


Picking up on last week's newsletter theme ("Sorry vegans, but humans were designed to eat (some) meat") here are some reflections based on the anthropology research I've been "boning up" on over the past couple of weeks.

Raw foods enthusiasts point to the health benefits of a diet consisting of fresh, uncooked vegetables, fruits, juices, raw nuts and seeds, sprouts, and smoothies. They sometimes cite evolutionary evidence that our distant primate ancestors subsisted on fresh plant foods.

Raw foods advocates also highlight the advantages of "live enzymes" and vitamins undamaged by heat or processing. There's certainly no dearth of fiber, which is deficient in the diets of most Westerners, in a raw foods diet. Moreover, the alkalinizing effects of the diet are considered a plus. And if the plant foods are cleanly sourced, they are relatively free of the pollutants that are embedded in the fats and protein of conventionally-raised animal products.

Additionally, because raw foods are not energy-dense, they provide mouth-feel and satiety without delivering many calories.

But carried to an extreme, raw foods dieting can have harmful consequences for humans. I've encountered many cases of fatigue and lassitude, brain fog, gastrointestinal bloating, multiple allergies and sensitivities, and premature osteoporosis in single-minded raw foods consumers.

In one memorable instance, a 60 year-old man came to see me after being diagnosed with profound osteoporosis. He had adhered to a raw foods vegan for the last 30 years. His diet consisted entirely of salads, raw vegetables, sprouts, raw nuts and seeds, and fruit smoothies. Upon testing, he had profound deficiencies of many key vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and essential fatty acids.

Fortunately, he was amenable to changing his diet and taking supplements. But as an afterthought, because he had a very high cholesterol and low HDL-in spite of consuming NO cholesterol or saturated fats whatsoever-I decided to send him for an EBT heart scan to measure the calcium accumulation in his arteries.

The results were astounding: He had a score of over 1400, which is associated with a very high risk of heart disease. I told him to see a cardiologist for a stress test in case the calcium was causing a critical blockage.

What then ensued still makes me feel a little queasy: I received a call from the gentleman from the hospital. After the stress test-which he failed miserably-the cardiologist decided to admit him immediately for an emergency angioplasty. I started to apologize for precipitating such a dire outcome, but the man insisted on thanking me profusely for sending him for the scan that revealed potential trouble. He was grateful for having "dodged a bullet" because he was likely to have had a heart attack eventually.

Ultimately, on a more balanced diet with avoidance of the excess fruit sugar he was imbibing with the juices and smoothies, this patient went on to improve his cardiac risk factors; with proper supplementation, he remineralized his depleted bones without the need for medication.

Why does the anthropological argument for a raw foods diet fail to pass muster? According to the latest evidence, it was precisely because proto-humans developed fire that we began the long march toward our present anatomical and cultural status. Fire enabled humans to cook food, breaking down the constituents of tough fibrous plants and unlocking the nutrients therein. It also enabled the consumption of sinewy animal proteins, which, if consumed raw, would've required massive jaws like those of carnivorous animals.

Moreover, fire enabled sterilization of slightly spoiled foods, like the scavenged remains of animals killed by more formidable predators like lions and hyenas; plant foods, too, could be resuscitated by cooking, even past their "expiration dates."

The nutrients thus harnessed enabled humans to spend less time foraging and chewing. In fact, modern wild primates expend over half their time individually searching for food and eating, leaving less surplus time and energy for cooperative endeavors that characterize modern humans.

Modern man's larger brains are high in macronutrient requirements, demanding 25% of total caloric intake, whereas monkey's brains subsist on less than 10%. Cooking unlocked the concentrated nutrients that launched a revolution in human brain size. One theory even has it that dietary cholesterol derived from (cooked) animal protein was a prerequisite to the evolution of the human brain-whose structural composition is rich in cholesterol and Omega-3 fatty acids. The high cholesterol composition of human breast milk underscores its essentiality to brain development (see Leyla's article below).

Cooking was also a seminal cultural activity, requiring communal participation in food preparation around a central hearth. Language and cooperation were essential to hunting, gathering, the making of tools, weapon, and utensils, and transmitting recipes. In fact, the famous anthropologist Claude Levi-Strauss made cooking synonymous with the development of culture in his landmark treatise entitled "The Raw and the Cooked."

Paleontologists have used sophisticated analysis to arrive at the conclusion that Neanderthals-forerunners of modern homo sapiens-consumed 55% of their diet as meat. While Neanderthals are extinct, genetic analysis reveals that contemporary Europeans possess around 2-4% Neanderthal DNA (mine, according to 23andme is 3.4%, slightly above average, perhaps accounting for my sloping forehead and prominent brow-ridge!)

To the argument that cooking food "destroys nutrients," it must be countered that, while there is some degradation of vitamins and other food constituents via heat, there is evidence that certain nutrients like the fat-soluble carotenoids lutein and lycopene are actually better absorbed when cooked with fat.

For example, try to envision eating a bowl full of raw collard greens. A daunting proposition. But when steamed and lightly saut?ed with garlic, these tough greens yield their full nutritional benefits.

Raw foods are fine when added generously to a balanced diet. I make sure I eat a big raw salad at least once a day. And exclusive consumption of raw foods may serve a purpose as an occasional short-term detox regimen, or to a jump-start a weight loss diet. But long-term reliance on raw foods is nutritionally imbalanced, and is not in accordance with our evolutionary programming.

Have a comment on this article? Send it.


 

Back to...

Health conditions and concerns

More in this group...

Vitamin c / atherosclerosis scare

Functional food science

Is your diet making you sick?

Drugs that steal

Iron: deficiency and toxicity

12 drugs you should never take (part 2 of 3)

12 supplements you should NEVER take

"Death by food pyramid": a review

"Don't take your vitamins"? So not!

"Fed Up": A movie review

Intelligent Medicine Bone Health Protocol available now!

Intelligent Medicine Health News Review

10 "Duh!" health and nutrition stories

10 simple hacks to improve your diet

10 ways the foods you eat can affect your sex life

11 reasons why you should be using extra virgin olive oil

11 things worth trying if you suffer from tinnitus

12 drugs you should never take (part 1 of 3)

12 drugs you should never take (part 3 of 3)

12 supplements you should NEVER take

13 tips for surviving the holidays (part one)

13 tips for surviving the holidays (part two)

16 reasons to go nuts for nuts

5 easy Paleo diet hacks

6 new products that I'm excited about in 2015

A nerd in the kitchen: My review of The Food Lab: Better Home Cooking Through Science by J. Kenji Lo

American Heart Association doubles down on outmoded saturated fat recommendations

Are "paleo snacks" an oxymoron?

Are fruit and veggie pills really as effective as they claim?

Are fruit and veggie pills really as effective as they claim?

Are vegetarians healthier than meat-eaters? So NOT, according to shocking new studies

Can a low-salt diet actually be BAD for you?

Can what you eat really damage your thyroid?

Clinical Focus: Nicotinamide Riboside

Confessions of an EX-vegan

Could a vegetarian diet undermine your mental health?

Could a vegetarian diet undermine your mental health?

Could Big Sugar become the next Big Tobacco?

Death by Food Pyramid? by Denise Minger: A Review

Defensive Eating: Taming your addiction to food

Detox in a box

Dispatches from the front lines of nutrition-what you need to know about the latest health headlines

Do you have SIBO (Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth)?

Do you really need to eat breakfast?

Frontline gets it wrong about supplements

GMO non-browning apples: A risky solution to a non-problem

Happy one millionth podcast! Let's review the best of 2015 so far

How a raw foods diet can make you sick

ICYMI: Dr. Hoffman's Store now available through Fullscript!

Iron: Do you want to hear the good news or the bad news first?

Is fructose really that bad for you?

Is the "pandemic" of vitamin D deficiency exaggerated?

Is the way to a (wo)man's heart through his(her) stomach?

Is the Whole30 diet right for you? (part one)

Is the Whole30 diet right for you? (part two)

Is your grill killing you? Your personal anti-AGEing program

More good news about olive leaf extract

Organic produce trumps conventional: Here's why!

Paleo pitfalls

Paleo Pitfalls

Pro-vegan website outs apostate meat-eaters

Repeat after me: "Hunger is my friend!"

Rethinking Super Size Me: Is it a Big Whopper?

Rethinking breakfast

Revisiting salt intake - are you eating too much or too little?

Sorry vegans, but humans were designed to eat (some) meat

Supplements that I take

The artificial sweetener controversy: who should you believe?

The Whole30: A review

The WORST health and nutrition stories of 2015

There's no "one-size-fits-all" diet, according to new research

To juice or not to juice?

Top 10 "duh!" health and nutrition stories of 2016

Vitamins can cause cancer-REALLY??

What do Bill Gates, eggs, and soylent green have in common?

What week is it, kiddies? Why, it's National Folic Acid Week!

Why I liberally indulge in high-test chocolate

Why you don't have to feel guilty about those Valentine's Day chocolates

Why you should keep taking your supplements

Will the "real" China study please stand up

Yet more reasons to go gluten-free