My foray into personalized genetic testing (part two)

By Dr. Ronald Hoffman


In Part One of this article, I discussed some of the limitations of Ancestry.com and 23andMe. So, wanting to take a deeper dive into my genetic traits, I crunched the raw data I'd received using several services which promise more comprehensive analysis.

First, I subscribed to www.LiveWello.com. LiveWello offers analysis based on SNPs (single-nucleotide polymorphisms) derived from Ancestry.com and 23andMe. It's better to do it with 23andMe, because Ancestry.com offers less genetic data on which to base an interpretation.

LiveWello is a little like an SNP-of-the-month club because, as new conclusions are reached about the correlation between genes and certain traits, they email you new updates. That's a good thing, because our understanding of the genome is constantly evolving. Also, there's community: subscribers weigh in with questions and discussions about their genetic profiles. You can "share" your information. It's kind of like a Facebook for genetics groupies.

To my mind, these LiveWello forums tend to be a little too wonky, with exaggerated concerns over esoteric genetic glitches. Intelligent but overly credulous lay people tend to place too much stock in our limited understanding of the implications of genetic variations, and get lost in the minutiae. Self-help can easily morph into navel-gazing.

LiveWello can be pricey, because they charge $2.50 a month, and that can add up over time. They do offer a free "basic plan" but that's a little like the free computer checkups that are essentially a come-on; they don't offer much and get you to sign on for added services. LiveWello even offers a "Premium +" program for $43.95/month that provides you a caregiver assistance capability with "telephone consultations with trained staff". But with the present uncertainty over the validity of genetic interpretation, I'm not sure that would offer you more than unwarranted conclusions. You could easily get sucked into your genetic vortex.

That being said, LiveWello offered me a much more comprehensive analysis of the data generated by Ancestry.com. There's pharmacogenetics information (my individualized response to drugs): for example, I'm likely to be more easily affected by the blood thinner Coumadin.

There's also nutrigenomic information: I have a common genetic variant (60% of Europeans) of the MTHFR gene at locus C677 that makes it more likely I need more B12, folate and B6. But it's not as simple as that: many genes affect the methylation pathway, and for some who seem to need more B vitamins, genetic roadblocks elsewhere cause them to become hyper-excited when they're given B vitamins. Moreover, there's even disagreement among methylation experts over the interpretation of these gene variants.

A cheap way to get a picture of your methylation pathways from raw data generated by 23andMe or Ancestry.com is to use GeneticGenie.com. You can upload one or the other to GeneticGenie, or both simultaneously. GeneticGenie asks for an optional $10 one-time contribution. But, as the boilerplate that accompanies your report will attest, there's no foolproof way to interpret your data.

Dr. Amy Yasko, an autism expert, offers a very comprehensive deciphering of your methylation pathway results via www.holisticheal.com, but her conclusions are idiosyncratic and controversial. (A detailed sample report can be found here.) She provides suggestions for nutritional support, but promotes her own proprietary supplements. For example, she slices and dices to differentiate which form of B12 is best keyed to your methylation cycle, an intriguing idea, but one which requires more research substantiation. As with many advanced genetic tests, the Yasko report is not available to residents of New York State, and it's pricey at $495. I did not submit my DNA results for a Yasko analysis.

On my report with LiveWello, around 50 genes related to methylation were listed. Most of mine were the good kind, but around a dozen were so-so, and eight were listed as "bad" mutations. Since I'm in good health and free of neurological problems, and I support myself with a wide array of nutritional supplements, I had to content myself with the impression that my assets have been sufficient to outweigh my liabilities.

As I mentioned, LiveWello also provided me with a series of "pharmacogenomic" reports that shed light on how I might respond to certain medications. But since I don't take prescription medications, this was of less relevance to me than a series of "variance" reports which hint at-but don't necessarily confirm-genetic Achilles' heels.

LiveWello even qualifies these reports with this disclaimer: "Variance reports can be overwhelming and difficult to decipher. To help you make sense of the genotypes in this report, try building a survey to poll other LiveWello users with similar genotypes.

OK, so that means I need to get into a LiveWello chat room with potentially unreliable interpreters of highly-subjective symptoms to see if we can make sense of our SNPs? Sounds like a recipe for tail-chasing and maybe mutually reinforcing hypochondriasis!

Of some concern to me was a double hit for recessive genes for MAO A and B. LiveWello blandly informs me that variations in these genes can be (sometimes, but not invariably) associated with "Parkinson's Disease, endogenous depression, Alzheimer's Disease, and dementia." But my variant of MAO A conforms to the "Warrior Gene," characterized by higher aggression scores and impulsiveness.

But another gene, COMT, also determines whether you're a "warrior" vs. a "worrier" and there I have a 50:50 genetic make-up. I've always thought of myself as sort of a cautious warrior. But we?ve got to be wary of simplistic conclusions; it's crucial to note that complex traits like personality may be the summation of dozens or even hundreds of genes.

It's complicated!

Now, my take: For my money (astonishingly cheap at $7), your best bet is Promethease. Promethease is a literature retrieval system that builds a personal DNA report based on connecting your file of DNA genotypes to a comprehensive, authoritative data bank of gene interpretations. The way it's set up, you can run a variety of reports.

Don't expect oracular pronouncements about your health destiny or detailed supplement recommendations from Promethease. In my profile, some gene locations forecast low risk of Alzheimer's, others high; I lack the classic "FOX" gene for longevity, but possess the gene that helps many Eastern European Jews become centenarians; I have a higher risk for certain cancers, but have mostly robust detox pathways that fend off carcinogenesis; some of my genes predict heightened academic aptitude, while others foretell susceptibility to ADD; I possess a few obesity genes, but nonetheless remain lean; and Promethease, like 23andMe, dutifully reported that I'm likely to go bald, although there's no sign of it at age 63.

There are a lot of ways to go with gene-testing, including tests which your doctor can order to predict which psychiatric drugs you're most likely to respond to (Genomind and SureGene), others which predict your reactions to common medications (YouScript). These may be ultimately the future of Personalized Medicine, helping to customize therapy in lieu of our current one-size-fits-all approach.

Still, after much investigation, while genetic analysis can yield some useful insights, I'm convinced it's not yet ready for prime time, especially for healthy individuals merely desiring guidance for disease prevention.

If you've undertaken some of these tests, I'm prepared to help you analyze them, but my conclusions will remain restrained until I?m persuaded there's more evidence that genetic data is actionable in a real-world sense.

To paraphrase William Shakespeare: "It is not in the genes to hold our destiny, but in ourselves."

(In a future newsletter, I'll share what I discovered when I submitted a stool sample to Ubiome.)

Have a comment on this article? Send it.


 

Back to...

Health conditions and concerns

More in this group...

Page  1 2

Anti-aging medicine

Reflections on "health"

Growing older and memory

12 drugs you should never take (part 2 of 3)

13 reasons why most health studies are wrong

13 tests your doctor is not likely to offer, but you should ask for anyway

14 supplements you should NEVER take - updated! (part one)

9 things your doctor doesn't know about supplements (but definitely should)

Want to live longer? Here's how!

What's your Health IQ? Take this test to find out!

"Don't take your vitamins"? So not!

"Don't take your vitamins?" so not!

Intelligent Medicine Bone Health Protocol available now!

Intelligent Medicine Health News Review

Intelligent Medicine Shorts:

10 epic medical fails: Bet most of you have fallen for at least one! (Part one)

10 responses to supplement naysayers

10 things I got right 30 years ago

10 ways the foods you eat can affect your sex life

11 ways you can predict how long you'll live

12 drugs you should never take (part 1 of 3)

12 drugs you should never take (part 3 of 3)

12 supplements you should NEVER take

13 holiday survival tips

13 tips for surviving the holidays (part one)

13 tips for surviving the holidays (part two)

13 tips for surviving the holidays: Part One

13 tips for surviving the holidays: Part two

14 supplements you should NEVER take - updated! (part two)

14 things YOU know better than your doctor

14 things YOU know better than your doctor

17 nutraceuticals that can boost your immune response

18 supplements that may stave off Alzheimer's

21 ways to save your liver!

24 ways we should fundamentally transform our healthcare system

28 things to be thankful for this Thanksgiving

6 new products that I'm excited about in 2015

8 reasons why the FDA's recent ban on anti-bacterial cleansers is a good idea

A year-end message from Intelligent Medicine

American Heart Association doubles down on outmoded saturated fat recommendations

Are some medicines stealing your brain power?

Beating the winter blahs

Book review: "the story of the human body", by Daniel E. Lieberman, Ph.D.

Can a low-salt diet actually be BAD for you?

Chill out--it may be healthy for you!

Click bait health reporting: I'm calling BS on these 5 health stories

Clinical Focus: Nicotinamide Riboside

Cold, painful fingertips? Try these remedies!

Could a vegetarian diet undermine your mental health?

Debating a skeptic

Debunking the top 7 supplement myths

Defensive Eating: Taming your addiction to food

Detox in a box

Diversify your exercise portfolio

Do you have "poor protoplasm"?

Do you have WWS (Work Withdrawal Syndrome)?

Does this plug-in make me look fat? and does it matter anyway?

Dr. Nicholas Gonzalez: In Memoriam

Exercise that I do

Five health victories we've already won

Four more drugs you should avoid

From wraith to warrior: Hoffman Center's Grimaldy Vargas triumphs in her first Spartan Sprint race!

Frontline gets it wrong about supplements

GMOs: a primer

Happy Fourth of July! Plan a health revolution, and what's in store for Intelligent Medicine

Happy one millionth podcast! Let's review the best of 2015 so far

How to protect yourself from the harmful effects of antibiotics

ICYMI: Dr. Hoffman's Store now available through Fullscript!

Innovative therapies for Multiple Sclerosis

Intravenous vitamin c validated by new studies

Iron: Do you want to hear the good news or the bad news first?

Is the way to a (wo)man's heart through his(her) stomach?

Is there really a vast conspiracy to deprive us of cures and profit off our misery?

Is your BBQ killing you? Your personal anti-AGEing program

Is your Coumadin killing you? (The remarkable potential of vitamin K to stop arterial calcification)

Is your doctor a psychopath?

Jurassic World: A parable

Listen to your gut: What your microbiome can tell you about your overall health

Medical evolution will affect you, but how?

Michele Obama's water advocacy based on 'murky' science, say experts

My foray into personalized genetic testing

My foray into personalized genetic testing (part two)

My triathlon comeback

Paint-by-numbers medicine (part one)

Part two: 10 epic medical fails you may have fallen for

PhytoGuard: Your 'one-stop-shop' for phytonutrient benefits

Pushing back on the supplement alarmists

Real healthcare reform

Repeat after me: "Hunger is my friend!"

Saving the VA hospitals

Should doctors be role models for their patients?

Spring detox

Stem Cells: Panacea or snake oil?

Supplement of the week: DIM

Tamiflu: Our first-line drug against the flu is an epic-fail

Test your "Health IQ" ? round three!

Test Your Health IQ: Round Five!

Test Your Health IQ: Round four!

The artificial sweetener controversy: who should you believe?

Page  1 2